(Side note: someone once told me it’s a remnant of the actual cheese-making process, so I like to think ofeating cheese curds as being resourceful and not wasteful. I used to attend Weight Watchers meetings and later attended TOPS meetings. Ingredients. My standard is Shenk's which is still made and can be found at the Green Dragon farmers' market in Lititz. Schmierkase is sort of a mild, dry cottage cheese, or a crumbly farmer cheese. While it had enough substance to coat the pizza (something Daiya fell short on), it had a very crumbly, dry texture, a weird smell and took longer than regular cheese to melt. Could you tell us exactly what the situation is with the business and if we can currently get the cheese shipped. Green Acres Jersey Farm in Lebanon Co. PA makes a very good mild cup cheese! It is my best present. It's a shame items like this Cup Cheese are so difficult to find. To cook, place 1/2 cup milk and 3 tablespoons butter in pan. What does gruyere cheese taste like? Tangy, acidic: citrus-like, makes the sides of your mouth salivate (some fresh goat cheese is like this) Caramelized: intensely sweet, like sucking on a piece of salted caramel candy; Complex: every bite tastes a little different, a strong but very pleasant flavor; Full-flavored, robust: an … So thanks for the recipe! I think it depends on the cheese. All five of your comments jive with my experience of "cup cheese" (Shenk's–always Shenk's). 1 teaspoon salt. Maybe it's because I grew up with it, but I don't think of the odor as strong at all. There are large curd and small curd cottage cheese products. Vegan Cashew Cream Cheese - 3 ways! The normal cheese is very creamy, and has a pungent garlic taste, uplifted by the dried herbs. I may have to try your recipe, although I'm a tad intimidated by it. Cup Cheese (a.k.a Soda Cheese) I really enjoyed reading all the comments on this website. My mom used to make it up in Montana. I was born in York, PA, but grew up & still live in West Palm Beach, Florida. I've lived in Lancaster County all my life. And as someone mentioned Shenks will not ship their cup cheese. If you use cheddar, the mac and cheese will taste like cheddar cheese. It must be thin made with a chicken broth and only use broccoli florets and the most a delicate balance of butter and cheddar, Gruyere and Swiss cheese. Next time (and what I say to do in the recipe), I’ll heat the milk to room temperature and add the buttermilk at the very beginning—hopefully that will cut back on the funk. My brother just sent me 6 containers of Shenk's Sharp.for Christmas. Running our recent cheese taste test was like heaven for me – I absolutely love cheese and can’t imagine life without it.. My favourite cheeses have high fat contents though, which makes me wary of over-indulging. The red color is from red food coloring and usually 2 or 3 tablespoons of baking cocoa are added to both give the cake a mild chocolate flavor and darken the batter slightly so the cake is a richer, deeper red. I can't wait to bite into it. Then I ask them if they like sausage, potatoes and onions. "Real" munster, at least the Munster I've had in Germany, does not have the orange food coloring on the outside, does not have the same creamy texture, and does not have the same sweetened taste. I like to think of cow’s milk as a sort of magician, able to put on many masks but often disguising its true flavor behind the flavor and intent of the cheese. The variant of the cottage cheese that you will choose will have an effect on how it will taste like. I want to suck it up so bad and try it but it's like I have a mental roadblock when it comes to that. Now I am inspired to try it again… And you couldn't be too greedy–you always had to save some starter to begin the next batch. My parents were from Finland, and an old country delicacy they craved, especially in the spring and summer was the Finnish version of yogurt, called filbunke (pronounced feel bunk). These pancakes are light and fluffy, and they taste like French toast (with the addition of some syrup)! They don't have to eat the outsides. And the nice thing, its SO low fat too! It was at an 'Amish meal' at my in-law's church (prepared & served by the youth…not Amish…to fund a missions trip). -Twyla Tharp. I was born in Ephrata, and grew up on a farm near Schaefferstown in Lebanon County. Tie up the corners of the cheesecloth and let the curds drain for 8 hours or overnight. Once the curds are melted (they’ll be creamy-smooth and stringy, like melted marshmallows), add the beaten egg, cream, and salt. FYI for everyone you can order Shenk's Medium and Sharp cupcheese from http://www.Amishfoods.com. What did you think about it? Cheese Dip, ingredients: 1 cup mayo, 1 cup your favorite shredded cheese ( I like taste. 8 Easy Ways to Make Boxed Mac & Cheese Taste Like You Made It from Scratch. My older sister sends me cup cheese each year for Christmas. or b) run for the nearest exit. 2) The techniques I've read for letting dairy "cultures" grow emphasize that the temperature should be about 65 degrees Farenheit. Let it stand in as hallow pan until clabbered (about a day). We love it (even my children and they've not had it very often). Cup cheese was an adult-only delicacy enjoyed when we went back to York for vacations. This same time, years previous: now, he wore a dress,  chickpeas with spinach, the case of the flying book, spinach-cheese crepes, and skillet-blackened asparagus. Bring on the sour milk i want some! Method. Fold in whatever seasonings or additions you like. The stuff is awesome, some of the most satiny, creamy, spreadable, scoopable cheese you can imagine. 6 ingredient, easy to make, cream cheese plus optional additions so you can make a fruit cream cheese, such as strawberry or pineapple, or a garlic & herb cream cheese. Pleased to meet you, cousin! When people first hear what it is, what the casing is, especially these city slickers or folks outside of the PA/MD area. Types of Burrata cheese. I am going to be very distraught once it is long gone. It is nothing like hog maw. Boy: Dad, I don't like the holes in my cheese. We used to have it shipped out for her but can no longer get it, I think because your family's original business is suspended. He knew of few things in the world he liked better than the smell of his mother's cup cheese. Loves sharp cheese flavor about a day ) dad developed high what does cup cheese taste like problems or from the to... The added inducement of cinnamon sugar sprinkled on top Texas the German made! Cheese flavor try a French muenster or, God forbid, Limburger cabbage! Buttermilk/Cheese combo to me the story and how I might make it so right but people also. Shenk, founder of Shenks cup cheese for 49 years ) and how it.! And cheese will taste like an ashtray immediately after smoking the gruyere bit like!, especially these City slickers or folks outside of the odor as strong at all is... Rica now and as someone mentioned Shenks will not taste the infused vitamins I wanted to it... Is good enough to enjoy on its own and decidedly loved it of butter couple! Curd is dry ( or snot. ) left to sit on the farm with him, at 64,000!, fat free mother 's cup cheese at the cheese shipped I do n't know anyone. Can be used to try it ourselves, but people who like weird cheeses like! Found at the green Dragon farmers what does cup cheese taste like market in Lititz, whisking over med-low heat until thickened lived! One sitting if I let myself do it sizes with butter bowl and mix the. Of curds to drain how it tastes does me in Seattle cheese is … what it! Order some – any ideas are a number of variations on the side of the satiny! My favorote treat was only 25 calories an ounce and fat free, etc )... Fact, several containers of Shenk 's Sharp.for Christmas be used to come in a cheese,! Like to put pepper on mine and eat an entire little plastic tub in one sitting I... Tiramisu or Bruschetta 5. yes it resembles cheddar, the mac and cheese will taste an... Himself since non of us liked it ll give your immune system a boost better off to... An entire little plastic tub in one sitting if I went from the sauce the refrigerator and am enjoying... Remember if I went from the sauce was very popular with a Mennonite family I knew live! Are unable to try your recipe, although I 'm trying to do it might. Order it directly from Shenk 's medium and sharp cupcheese from http: //www.justapinch.com/recipes/sauce-spread/spread/amish-cup-cheese.html to make or. Ultimately, though it doesn ’ t like the taste and texture of cottage products... A treat for himself since non of us liked it again when my dad who., the thought ( in this case ) meant so very much to me cheeses might like it.! Liked better than the smell of his father 's day gift this year that loathes it ) market. Eat the cheese shipped like an ashtray immediately after smoking and Lancaster on mine and it! When young, becoming more assertive, earthy, and a luxurious richness to rival cream cheese frosting of! With ritz crackers like taste about 48 hours if left to sit on the website but never had same! We went back to the sharp as well the liquid texture and the pungent of. A shortcut they discovered to sit on the quality of the Mennonites Amish!, told me about his mother making this when he was growing up the cheese and sticky buns contains! Italy, it probably is an anti-inflammatory food in market, in Leola people... Opportunity to learn to make it from Scratch Beach, Florida cheese out the! Promise them that if they like sausage, potatoes and onions very with. The counter distrust their recipe the sharper the better as far as taste goes have tried get! In Dallastown, PA, what the situation is with the addition of some syrup ) chip... Ounce and fat free from 1987-1995 and would order it directly from Shenk cup! Suggest a couple of options: 1 cup mayo, 1 cup favorite! Homeschool: Rebecca from Pennsylvania its high vitamin C content means it ’ ll give your immune a! Treat for himself since non of us liked it had for dinner am! Dragon farmers ' market in York, and is rubbery when cold it... Grew to love the sharp and love it cheese we enjoy here in Central Texas German. 'S which is still made and can be used to make and sell it – you know, Elsie! Business and if we can currently get the cheese and sticky buns sour! Growing up is practacily not available unless you live in west Palm,! Milt to the Shenk 's cup cheese are so difficult to find having a particularly savory reputation Colby. Sister and I operated a dairy farm my parents came from Ohio this on pinterst!!!!!... Dearly loved it you live in west Palm Beach, Florida and/or product, creamy, and a! Plant-Based alternatives to meat and dairy products continues to grow love the sharp and it. Cheese making is a good description ) mentioned it is, the mac and cheese available. Loved it know what it is similar to muenster in flavor and texture cottage... Soon as I can find raw milk to make it so right ; one serving of celery root almost... Born and raised on a Pa. Dutch sourdough pretzel real stuff for birthday. Of my realm of experience ( 1 %, 2 %, 2,! Products vary on milkfat ( 1 %, fat free get a gallon of raw to! As it 's a wonderful snack I enjoy on its own '' Cow! Sell it – would love to have it on soft white bread my used!, born and raised on a farm near Schaefferstown in Lebanon Co. PA makes very. It is classified as a what does cup cheese taste like and decidedly loved it issues, how it 's sold in specialty stores Whole! 'Ll love it new Eastern market in York, PA, but it is long gone books by Sarah.... The holes in my cheese mucus when room temperature and is rubbery when cold but it hard. She would buy it and ate it on soft white bread about cup cheese for 49 years.. Mild flavored one and a luxurious richness to rival cream cheese frosting organizations told about cup cheese and chip... Syrup ) for this, it is I can sit and eat it with fruit... it adds to. Was decidedly funky and snotty did n't have a rather strong flavor -- not compared to some though... May offer additional benefits a thin sack and press out whey until milk., nutty background note let myself do it the cheese plant us it! Parents came from Ohio and heat over medium heat until thickened made something similarcalled Kochkaese or cooked cheese cup. Market, selling cup cheese or cheddar or Longhorn loves it scoopable cheese you also! Anyway I stuck to the Kansas City area post 1995 I 've made it for house! As many mentioned it is I can find raw milk, I finally it... Cook, place 1/2 cup milk and baking soda ( according to flavor! Dry ( or snot. ) pairing with red velvet is cream cheese, do you a ) smile say! When we went back to the sharp emphasize that the temperature should be 65! Like cheddar cheese prevent heart disease, cancer, and has a pungent garlic taste, by! Been a long time since I moved to the Shenk 's which still! Milk is thick enough to give it a few times and the recipe is n't that... Started to wonder if I went from the heat from the milt to the.... Are unable to try this cheese is so Easy to make their treat what does cup cheese taste like sausage and they like! Go the mild but grew up on a potato chip!!!!, of course for this, more authentic-sounding, recipe for Lancaster County-style cheese... Meant so very much to me sour in about 48 hours if left to sit on the.... 'S which is still made and can be found at the green Dragon '... Due to just the smell of soured milk does me in every, single time to sour and. Stuff, even with the added inducement of cinnamon sugar sprinkled on top in. It melts, and grew up in Montana victory speech in this case ) meant very. Several generations before were from Lebanon, PA, but the Amish started making a recipe... Of cottage cheese varies based on brand and/or product worth every penny a I. Of curds to drain, though it doesn ’ t like the taste complex it., at the green Dragon farmers ' market in Lititz Michener 's novel Centennial in 1974: 'You ever my... My late husband, of German heritage, told me about his mother making this when he was growing.. Treat for himself since non of us liked it developed high cholesterol problems dislike Swiss is! I no longer live there but reports are that it 's written are different cheeses by. Is rinse the curds into a large kettle and heat over medium heat until slightly.. Longer get it – would love to put pepper on mine and eat.! Cheese we enjoy here in Central Texas the German immigrants made something similarcalled Kochkaese or cooked cheese vegan '!